Week 1 · 2024

Carl vs Rob

Slot-by-slot. The full benches. The lineup decisions that decided it.

Carl123.9

Margin 26.1

Rob97.7100 got they ass

Slot Face-Off

Starting Lineups

Jayden Daniels28.2

QB#2 QB this week

QB+11.7

Jalen Hurts16.4

QB#6 QB this week

Alvin Kamara22.0

RB#5 RB this week

RB1+5.4

Rachaad White16.6

RB#9 RB this week

Jahmyr Gibbs17.4

RB#8 RB this week

RB2+1.6

Isiah Pacheco15.8

RB#11 RB this week

Deebo Samuel Sr.18.7

WR#5 WR this week

WR1+6.5

Ja'Marr Chase12.2

WR#12 WR this week

Amon-Ra St. Brown4.3

WR#19 WR this week

WR2-6.8

Zay Flowers11.1

WR#14 WR this week

George Kittle8.0

TE#4 TE this week

TE+6.5

Evan Engram1.5

TE#9 TE this week

James Cook13.3

RB#13 RB this week

FLEX+6.2

Michael Pittman Jr.7.1

WR#18 WR this week

Greg Zuerlein1.0

K#8 K this week

K-8.0

Harrison Butker9.0

K#6 K this week

Seahawks D/ST11.0

DEF#3 DEF this week

DEF+3.0

Dolphins D/ST8.0

DEF#4 DEF this week

Show benches (14 players)

Carl’s bench

Rob’s bench

Coaching Decisions

Lineup Diff

Where each manager’s actual lineup differed from the optimal one.

Carl

Left 15.0 on the bench. Started for 123.9; optimal was 138.9.

WR2Sat Brian Thomas Jr. (14.7) for Amon-Ra St. Brown (4.3)−10.4
FLEXSat Jahmyr Gibbs (17.4) for James Cook (13.3)−4.1
RB2Sat Brian Robinson Jr. (17.9) for Jahmyr Gibbs (17.4)−0.5

Rob

Left 15.8 on the bench. Started for 97.7; optimal was 113.5.

FLEXSat Isiah Pacheco (15.8) for Michael Pittman Jr. (7.1)−8.7
RB1Sat J.K. Dobbins (22.9) for Rachaad White (16.6)−6.3
RB2Sat Rachaad White (16.6) for Isiah Pacheco (15.8)−0.8

Carl optimal

138.9

Left 15.0 on the bench

Rob optimal

113.5

Left 15.8 on the bench

← All Week 1 matchups Carl vs Rob rivalry →

Other Week 1 matchups

What happened in 2024