Week 12 · 2024

Cliff vs Mitch

Slot-by-slot. The full benches. The lineup decisions that decided it.

Cliff136.4

Margin 2.0

Mitch134.4

Slot Face-Off

Starting Lineups

Justin Herbert17.6

QB#5 QB this week

QB-5.0

Lamar Jackson22.6

QB#2 QB this week

Saquon Barkley46.2

RB#1 RB this week

RB1+29.9

David Montgomery16.3

RB#9 RB this week

Najee Harris7.4

RB#19 RB this week

RB2-6.6

Derrick Henry14.0

RB#11 RB this week

Jerry Jeudy14.5

WR#7 WR this week

WR1-8.4

A.J. Brown22.9

WR#1 WR this week

Malik Nabers12.4

WR#8 WR this week

WR2+2.6

Tyreek Hill9.8

WR#14 WR this week

Zach Ertz15.8

TE#5 TE this week

TE-9.5

Trey McBride25.3

TE#1 TE this week

Jonathan Taylor3.5

RB#20 RB this week

FLEX-6.0

Joe Mixon9.5

RB#16 RB this week

Ka'imi Fairbairn10.0

K#2 K this week

K+2.0

Jake Bates8.0

K#5 K this week

Eagles D/ST9.0

DEF#3 DEF this week

DEF+3.0

Vikings D/ST6.0

DEF#6 DEF this week

Show benches (9 players)

Cliff’s bench

Mitch’s bench

Coaching Decisions

Lineup Diff

Where each manager’s actual lineup differed from the optimal one.

Cliff

Left 6.0 on the bench. Started for 136.4; optimal was 142.4.

FLEXSat Najee Harris (7.4) for Jonathan Taylor (3.5)−3.9
RB2Sat D'Andre Swift (9.5) for Najee Harris (7.4)−2.1

Mitch

Left 38.3 on the bench. Started for 134.4; optimal was 172.7.

WR2Sat DJ Moore (26.9) for Tyreek Hill (9.8)−17.1
FLEXSat A.J. Brown (22.9) for Joe Mixon (9.5)−13.4
WR1Sat Courtland Sutton (29.7) for A.J. Brown (22.9)−6.8
DEFSat Steelers D/ST (7.0) for Vikings D/ST (6.0)−1.0

Cliff optimal

142.4

Left 6.0 on the bench

Mitch optimal

172.7

Left 38.3 on the bench

← All Week 12 matchups Cliff vs Mitch rivalry →

Other Week 12 matchups

What happened in 2024