Week 3 · 2025

Mitch vs Rob

Slot-by-slot. The full benches. The lineup decisions that decided it.

Mitch132.4

Margin 37.4

Rob95.1100 got they ass

Slot Face-Off

Starting Lineups

Lamar Jackson27.0

QB#3 QB this week

QB+13.9

Patrick Mahomes13.2

QB#7 QB this week

Christian McCaffrey24.0

RB#3 RB this week

RB1+11.6

Josh Jacobs12.4

RB#11 RB this week

Chuba Hubbard9.6

RB#15 RB this week

RB2-2.0

Travis Etienne Jr.11.6

RB#13 RB this week

Puka Nacua22.8

WR#2 WR this week

WR1+3.5

Michael Pittman Jr.19.3

WR#6 WR this week

Cooper Kupp5.1

WR#17 WR this week

WR2-7.4

Justin Jefferson12.5

WR#10 WR this week

Trey McBride15.3

TE#1 TE this week

TE+8.5

Zach Ertz6.8

TE#6 TE this week

Rhamondre Stevenson4.6

RB#19 RB this week

FLEX+1.3

Zay Flowers3.3

WR#20 WR this week

Matt Prater7.0

K#6 K this week

K-5.0

Harrison Butker12.0

K#2 K this week

Seahawks D/ST17.0

DEF#2 DEF this week

DEF+13.0

Bills D/ST4.0

DEF#7 DEF this week

Show benches (12 players)

Mitch’s bench

Rob’s bench

Coaching Decisions

Lineup Diff

Where each manager’s actual lineup differed from the optimal one.

Mitch

Left 44.0 on the bench. Started for 132.4; optimal was 176.4.

WR2Sat Puka Nacua (22.8) for Cooper Kupp (5.1)−17.7
RB2Sat Christian McCaffrey (24.0) for Chuba Hubbard (9.6)−14.4
FLEXSat Jacory Croskey-Merritt (10.1) for Rhamondre Stevenson (4.6)−5.5
RB1Sat David Montgomery (29.4) for Christian McCaffrey (24.0)−5.4
WR1Sat Courtland Sutton (23.8) for Puka Nacua (22.8)−1.0

Rob

Left 17.3 on the bench. Started for 95.1; optimal was 112.4.

FLEXSat Chris Olave (15.7) for Zay Flowers (3.3)−12.4
WR2Sat Tyreek Hill (15.9) for Justin Jefferson (12.5)−3.4
RB2Sat Josh Jacobs (12.4) for Travis Etienne Jr. (11.6)−0.8
RB1Sat Jaylen Warren (13.1) for Josh Jacobs (12.4)−0.7

Mitch optimal

176.4

Left 44.0 on the bench

Rob optimal

112.4

Left 17.3 on the bench

← All Week 3 matchups Mitch vs Rob rivalry →

Other Week 3 matchups

What happened in 2025