Eight Men, One Player Each
Keepers locked Saturday evening. The league spent the preceding forty-eight hours arguing that it could not possibly choose a keeper without first knowing how much losing would hurt.
By Kyle Andrus · Tribune Staff · with the Records Desk
BRIGHAM CITY — The keeper window closed at 6:18 o'clock Saturday evening, and eight franchises now stand committed to one player apiece for a draft that has not been held, at a price measured in selections they will never get to make.
The rule is unchanged and unambiguous. A keeper costs the pick one round above where the player was taken the previous year: an eleventh-round man costs a tenth, a second-round man costs a first, and a first-round man cannot be kept at all, there being no round above the first. That last clause appears to be news to the league's software, and produced the only formal crisis of the week — see the adjacent column.
What the rule did not anticipate was the argument it started. For two days this league conducted a referendum not on players but on nerve, and it turned on an accident of the calendar: the keeper deadline arrived before the season's last-place punishment had been set. Eight men were asked to make permanent decisions without being told the cost of failure.
The objection originated with Sanjay's Warriors and began as a procedural complaint. It did not remain one. Within the hour the league had talked itself into open risk-aversion — the Good Ghandis declaring an intention to play not to lose, the Chubby Chasers disclosing that a lighter penalty would have moved them to keep a team defense, a sentence this newspaper prints without comment and expects to be quoting for a decade.
Mr. Clegg then reasoned aloud between a bold running back and a safe one, and was answered by the commissioner with a two-line eulogy for his season and by Mr. Israelsen with a photograph of a Greek warrior promising that no one would remember his name. He countered by proposing that the year's punishment be a tattoo, in order to establish how brave the rest of them actually are. The proposal has not been withdrawn.
The rebuttal, when it came, came from the man who had just confessed to the cowardice himself.
“Maybe you and I never win because we play with too much cowardice. Be bold Cliff.”— Caden Didericksen, on the keeper market
He then kept a rookie running back for a twelfth-round pick and was vindicated by the arithmetic inside the hour — the first occasion in nine years on which Mr. Didericksen has been right about something in advance rather than in hindsight.
The full ledger, with this newspaper's rulings on all eight selections, appears below. One finding may be stated here. The most valuable keeper in the league belongs to a man who has been a member of it for thirteen days and who did not draft the player. Rob Ercanbrack did, in the eleventh round of a season that ended in last place, and then retired and left it behind.
